10 Yankees Who Deserved More Credit — From Wang to Stottlemyre
GOATIFYBeing remembered as a New York Yankee is not the same thing as being properly appreciated as one. The franchise has more icons, October legends and Hall of Fame names than almost any club can fit into a single conversation. That makes the middle layer of Yankees history especially easy to overlook: players who were genuinely excellent, sometimes for years, but whose peaks landed between dynasties, beside bigger stars or in roles that did not create the same mythology.
This list is about that layer. It is not a collection of obscure names pulled from old rosters. Every player here produced real value in New York, and several were among the better players at their positions in the league during their Yankees runs. What keeps them underrated is context. Some arrived immediately after or before a championship window. Some played next to household names. Some were remembered for one postseason moment even though their regular-season body of work was much stronger than that single highlight suggests.
From Chien-Ming Wang's brief run as a frontline starter to Mel Stottlemyre's decade of excellence during one of the franchise's quieter eras, these are 10 Yankees whose New York careers deserve more credit.
10-8: Chien-Ming Wang, Scott Brosius and Didi Gregorius
10. Chien-Ming Wang
Chien-Ming Wang's Yankees peak was short enough that it can disappear when fans jump from the late dynasty years straight to the 2009 championship. From 2005 through 2009, he made 104 starts for New York and went 55-26. The overall 4.16 ERA does not capture how good he was before a severe right-foot injury changed the direction of his career.
The clearest case comes from 2006 and 2007. Wang went 19-6 with a 3.63 ERA over 218 innings in 2006, producing 6.0 WAR and finishing second in American League Cy Young voting. He followed it with another 19-win season, a 3.70 ERA and 199.1 innings in 2007. Across those two years, he gave the Yankees volume, efficiency and stability while sharing a staff with far more famous names such as Roger Clemens, Mike Mussina, Randy Johnson and Andy Pettitte.
That is why Wang's place in Yankees memory feels smaller than his actual peak. He was not just a useful starter during a transition period. For two seasons, he was arguably the most valuable arm in a rotation filled with stars. His injury at age 28 prevented that prime from becoming a longer résumé, but it should not erase what came before it.
9. Scott Brosius
Scott Brosius is remembered, but often for the wrong reason. His Yankees identity is tied so tightly to October that his regular-season value gets flattened into the label of postseason hero. He arrived from Oakland before the 1998 season and immediately became the everyday third baseman on a team that would win three consecutive World Series titles.
The famous moments are legitimate: Brosius was the 1998 World Series MVP, and his game-tying home run with two outs in the ninth inning of Game 5 of the 2001 World Series became another piece of Yankees postseason history. But 1998 was not merely a hot playoff run. Brosius generated 5.3 WAR that season, trailing only Derek Jeter and Paul O'Neill on a historically dominant roster. He also won a Gold Glove in 1999.
His four-year Yankees line—540 games, a .267/.331/.428 slash line, 65 home runs and 8.3 WAR—shows a player who contributed on both sides of the ball. The October résumé made him famous. Ironically, it also made it easier to underrate everything else he gave New York.
8. Didi Gregorius
Replacing Derek Jeter at shortstop was one of the least forgiving jobs in baseball. Didi Gregorius took it anyway. Acquired from Arizona in a three-team trade after Jeter's final season, Gregorius became New York's primary shortstop from 2015 through 2019 and gave the position something the Yankees have struggled to reproduce consistently since.
In 660 games, Gregorius posted a .269/.313/.446 line with 97 home runs and 14.8 WAR. More importantly, his strongest four-season stretch from 2015 through 2018 compared well with an elite group of major-league shortstops. His 14.5 WAR over that span trailed Francisco Lindor, Andrelton Simmons, Carlos Correa, Xander Bogaerts and Brandon Crawford, but kept him firmly in that upper tier. He also received MVP votes twice.
The shadow of Jeter made a good successor feel less dramatic than it should have. Gregorius never needed to become the previous captain. He only needed to give the Yankees high-level shortstop play, power and dependable production. For several seasons, that is exactly what he did.
7-5: Dave Righetti, Roberto Kelly and Jimmy Key
7. Dave Righetti
Dave Righetti's Yankees career is unusual enough that it can be difficult to place. He was the 1981 American League Rookie of the Year as a starter, threw a no-hitter in 1983, then moved into the bullpen in 1984 to replace Goose Gossage as the closer. That transition did not happen because Righetti had stopped being effective in the rotation. It happened just as he was entering his prime.
In 1983, Righetti made 31 starts, went 14-8 with a 3.44 ERA, struck out 169 and worked 217 innings. One year later, he appeared in 64 games, saved 31, posted a 2.34 ERA and still generated 3.3 WAR. By 1986, he had set what was then the single-season saves record with 46.
Over his Yankees tenure from 1979 through 1990, Righetti pitched in 522 games, made 76 starts, saved 224 and posted a 3.11 ERA over 1,136.2 innings. Those 224 saves remain one of the largest totals in franchise history. Modern baseball makes the path look even stranger: a quality starter in his mid-20s would almost never be moved permanently to the ninth inning today. Righetti handled the switch so well that the versatility itself can hide how valuable he was.
6. Roberto Kelly
Roberto Kelly has an awkward place in Yankees history because the transaction that ended his first New York stint became more famous than the years that preceded it. The Yankees signed him out of Panama as a teenager, developed him into their center fielder and watched him become an All-Star. Then they traded him to Cincinnati for Paul O'Neill, who became a central figure in the next Yankees dynasty.
That trade was a huge win for New York, but it should not turn Kelly into a footnote. From 1989 through 1992, he hit .281/.334/.415, averaged roughly 14 home runs and 34 stolen bases per season and produced about 3.2 WAR a year. He made the All-Star team in 1992. Across his Yankees career, including a brief return in 2000, he played 648 games, stole 151 bases and finished with a 107 OPS+.
Homegrown Yankees outfielders who develop into All-Stars are rarer than the franchise's history of famous outfielders might suggest. Kelly belongs in that conversation. Being the player traded for O'Neill should not be the only sentence attached to his New York career.
5. Jimmy Key
Jimmy Key arrived when the Yankees were trying to become serious contenders again. After missing on other major pitching targets before the 1993 season, New York signed the veteran left-hander to a four-year deal. He immediately became the staff's anchor.
Key went 18-6 with a 3.00 ERA over 236.2 innings in his first Yankees season, producing 6.3 WAR and finishing fourth in Cy Young voting. In the strike-shortened 1994 season, he went 17-4 with a 3.27 ERA and 4.4 WAR in only 25 starts, finishing second in the Cy Young race. Those were not merely solid veteran seasons. For two years, Key was one of the American League's best starting pitchers.
Injuries limited him in 1995, but his Yankees run still ended with a fitting moment: he was the winning pitcher in Game 6 of the 1996 World Series, the victory that completed New York's first championship since 1978. His four-year New York record was 48-23 with a 3.68 ERA. The later dynasty produced more celebrated pitchers, but Key helped build the bridge into it.
4-3: Gil McDougald and Ramiro Mendoza
4. Gil McDougald
Gil McDougald is the rare player who can win five World Series, make six All-Star teams and still be overshadowed. That is what happens when a career overlaps with Mickey Mantle, Joe DiMaggio, Yogi Berra, Whitey Ford and Phil Rizzuto. McDougald played his entire 10-year career with the Yankees from 1951 through 1960, appearing in eight World Series and collecting five rings.
His value went well beyond being another good player on stacked teams. McDougald won the 1951 American League Rookie of the Year award and played extensive innings at second base, shortstop and third base in an era when that degree of defensive flexibility was far less common. He hit .276/.356/.410 with 112 home runs and accumulated 40.9 WAR in only 1,336 games.
The consistency is what stands out most. McDougald produced at least 3 WAR in nine of his 10 big-league seasons. That is the profile of a star, not a role player riding the coattails of a dynasty. He simply had the historical misfortune of sharing the stage with some of the most famous Yankees ever.
3. Ramiro Mendoza
Ramiro Mendoza's value came from never requiring the Yankees to define him narrowly. He could start, relieve, absorb innings, finish a game or take over in the middle of a postseason pressure spot. On teams loaded with recognizable stars, the ability to solve whichever pitching problem appeared next made him exceptionally useful.
The 1998 season is the best illustration. Mendoza appeared in 41 games, started 14, went 10-2 with a 3.25 ERA and worked 130.1 innings. In May, he threw a five-hit shutout. In July, he recorded a 2.2-inning save. In Game 6 of the American League Championship Series, he delivered three scoreless innings across the sixth, seventh and eighth. That is three very different jobs from one pitcher in the same season.
Mendoza spent most of his Yankees career from 1996 through 2002, then returned briefly in 2005. He finished his New York tenure with 278 appearances, 57 starts, a 54-34 record and 699.2 innings. He was especially important on the 1998 and 1999 championship clubs. Swingmen rarely become franchise icons, but dynasties need pitchers who make imperfect roster days manageable. Mendoza did that repeatedly.
2-1: Mike Stanley and Mel Stottlemyre
2. Mike Stanley
Mike Stanley did not arrive in New York with the résumé of a future Yankees standout. He was 29, had spent six largely unremarkable seasons as a part-time player with Texas and joined the organization on a minor-league deal. By 1993, he had become one of the better offensive catchers in baseball.
From 1993 through 1995, Stanley produced a 136 OPS+, averaged 20 home runs and 75 RBI and reached at least 3 WAR in each season. He won a Silver Slugger and made an All-Star team. Across his Yankees stints from 1992 through 1995 and again in 1997, he hit .285/.377/.504 with 72 home runs in 426 games and finished with a 134 OPS+.
That three-year peak puts him in rare company among Yankees catchers. Yogi Berra, Bill Dickey, Thurman Munson, Jorge Posada and Elston Howard naturally dominate the position's franchise history, while Gary Sánchez's power era remains fresh in modern memory. Stanley's name slips between those groups even though his best seasons were legitimately excellent. For a team moving from mediocrity toward contention, he was a major offensive piece.
1. Mel Stottlemyre
Mel Stottlemyre is the clearest example of how timing can reshape a Yankees legacy. He debuted in 1964, when New York reached the World Series, and retired after 1974. The Yankees did not return to the Fall Classic until 1976. His entire prime therefore landed inside a championship drought that sits between two much more celebrated eras of franchise history.
That gap hides an outstanding career. Stottlemyre started 356 games for the Yankees, went 164-139 with a 2.97 ERA and threw 2,661.1 innings. He made five All-Star teams. His name remains scattered throughout the franchise pitching leaderboards: 164 wins, 1,257 strikeouts, 152 complete games and 40 shutouts. He generated 40.7 WAR despite never getting the kind of October platform that made so many other Yankees pitchers immortal in popular memory.
His only postseason experience came as a 22-year-old rookie in the 1964 World Series. He made three starts against St. Louis, went 1-1 with a 3.15 ERA over 20 innings and even beat Bob Gibson in Game 2. That should have been the beginning of a long October résumé. Instead, the franchise entered a down cycle around him.
Stottlemyre later returned to the Yankees as pitching coach from 1996 through 2005, meaning many fans remember him more readily from the dugout during the dynasty than from the mound during his own prime. That second chapter added to his legacy, but it also reinforces the central point: his playing career deserves to stand on its own. Among Yankees stars who missed the franchise's biggest winning windows, few have a stronger claim to being underrated.
Why “underrated” is different in Yankees history
The Yankees make this exercise harder than almost any other franchise because their baseline for historical fame is unusually high. A player can be an All-Star, receive award votes, win championships or rank among the franchise leaders in a major category and still sit behind a queue of Hall of Famers and October icons.
That is why the names on this list are connected less by style than by circumstance. Wang lost a potentially longer prime to injury. Brosius became so synonymous with the postseason that his broader value was diminished. Gregorius inherited an impossible position after Jeter. Righetti succeeded in two fundamentally different pitching jobs. Kelly became best known for the star acquired in exchange for him. Key helped restore a contender before the dynasty fully arrived. McDougald shared a clubhouse with legends. Mendoza excelled in a role that rarely produces fame. Stanley peaked at a position overflowing with Yankees icons. Stottlemyre spent almost his entire career between pennants.
None of that means these players should be elevated above the franchise's true inner circle. It means their actual Yankees careers deserve to be remembered at their proper scale. In a history dominated by the biggest names in baseball, being one tier below famous can still mean being very, very good.
There is also a useful reminder here about how baseball memory works. Peaks are easier to preserve when they end with a trophy, a signature October swing or a career spent entirely inside one dominant era. The Yankees have so many of those stories that excellent seasons outside the brightest windows can fade unusually fast. Wang's Cy Young-level stretch, Key's ace seasons, Stanley's offensive peak and McDougald's year-after-year production would be foundational history for plenty of clubs. In New York, they can become secondary chapters.
That does not make the famous Yankees overrated. It makes the franchise's second tier unusually deep. Looking back at these careers with the numbers and context restored is a better way to understand how much winning baseball happened between the headline names.
GOATIFY Baseball Collection
Baseball shirts, hoodies, stickers and fan gear built for people who live for the game.
