Anthony Richardson wearing the Indianapolis Colts uniform in 2026

Colts Cut Daniel Jones. Richardson Gets the Job—and the Mess.

GOATIFY

Indianapolis did not merely make a quarterback change after Thursday night’s 26–3 loss in Houston. It removed the quarterback around whom it had planned the season. On Friday, November 20, the Colts waived Daniel Jones and named Anthony Richardson Sr. their new starter. Jones had been signed to a two-year, $88 million deal in March after inspiring hopes of stability. Eight months later, a 3–8 record and one of the ugliest offensive performances of the season have changed the franchise’s direction.

The shock is less that Shane Steichen decided he needed a different starter than that Indianapolis ended the relationship outright. Benching Jones would have preserved a veteran option and allowed an easier reversal. Waiving him instead sends a much louder message: the club sees more value in evaluating its future than in extending a partnership that no longer has a credible path forward. Richardson, the fourth overall pick in 2023, now receives another chance to prove there is a franchise quarterback somewhere inside his extraordinary physical tools.

That does not mean Thursday’s defeat can be pinned on Jones alone. The Colts have traded significant veterans, dismissed their longtime general manager and struggled to generate consistent protection and explosive plays. Richardson will inherit the same instability. The real story is therefore a two-sided gamble: Indianapolis is admitting that one expensive quarterback plan failed while asking a previous, unfinished plan to make sense of the rubble.

Why the Colts Went Beyond Benching Daniel Jones

Daniel Jones and Indianapolis Colts quarterbacks during a team practice

The timing makes Indianapolis’ decision impossible to separate from the Thursday-night humiliation. Houston held the Colts to three points in a 26–3 game that quickly became more revealing than competitive. Jones completed 12 of 27 passes for 144 yards, threw an interception and finished with a 45.9 passer rating. Those numbers describe a bad outing, but they also capture the loss of trust in an offense that could not move the ball when it mattered. A team can survive one terrible game. It is much harder to survive the sense that every possession is another invitation to the same failure.

The larger sample was equally difficult to defend. Through eleven starts in 2026, Jones had thrown for 1,974 yards, seven touchdowns and 13 interceptions. The league-leading interception figure was paired with five fumbles, three of them lost, creating 16 giveaways across those eleven games. His 58.4 percent completion rate and 65.4 passer rating are not merely a step down from his strongest stretches in Indianapolis; they are the sort of production that leaves an entire offensive staff designing around what not to ask its quarterback to do.

The contrast with 2025 is essential. Jones joined the Colts seeking a career reset and briefly looked like a player who could deliver it. His first Colts season included a highly efficient stretch before a broken leg and eventually a torn Achilles interrupted the surge. He returned in roughly eight and a half months, a recovery that speaks to his commitment and toughness. That achievement deserves to stand separately from the results that followed. Coming back to play does not guarantee that the same timing, mobility and pocket confidence will immediately come back with him.

Steichen declined to characterize the move as Jones’ request and acknowledged that more than one person contributed to the collapse. That matters because it would be too convenient for a franchise to attach an entire failed season to the player whose name appears in the box score. Quarterbacks make visible mistakes; protection breakdowns, poor spacing, receiver separation, questionable sequencing and a weak defensive performance often remain harder to assign. The final Houston score made the entire organization look miles from the version of itself it had imagined.

Yet a waiver is also different from an ordinary depth-chart adjustment. The club could have preserved Jones as insurance for Richardson, particularly given the younger quarterback’s uneven history. Instead it created a clean vacancy and accepted the possibility that another team might claim him. Jones was placed on waivers through Monday, November 23, with the reported remaining 2026 salary and future non-guaranteed obligations relevant to potential bidders. His next destination is unknown, and a release should not be confused with either a guaranteed new contract or retirement.

From the Colts’ perspective, retaining the veteran may have made the final six games less useful. If the coaching staff already believes the long-term investment is finished, every additional Jones start would consume an opportunity to evaluate a younger quarterback in live conditions. That does not excuse the financial cost of the original decision. It clarifies why the club might choose a painful, immediate admission over a more comfortable delay.

The harshest verdict concerns roster planning. Indianapolis committed major money to Jones after a season disrupted by serious injury, then watched his accuracy and ball security deteriorate as losses piled up. The decision was made during a front-office transition, after general manager Chris Ballard was dismissed and several established contributors were traded. The franchise is no longer measuring whether Jones can keep a 2026 playoff chase alive. It is measuring which assumptions from its recent past need to be abandoned before the next one begins.

Anthony Richardson Has the Job—but Not a Free Pass

Anthony Richardson in Indianapolis Colts gear during quarterback training

Richardson’s return makes this more interesting than a routine late-season quarterback replacement. The Colts spent the fourth overall pick on him in 2023 because his combination of arm strength, size and running ability offered a ceiling few prospects could match. Those traits have never disappeared. What has remained uncertain is whether he can translate them into dependable down-to-down decisions, controlled ball placement and a passing game that works before a play dissolves.

The record explains both the optimism and the doubt. Across 19 NFL appearances, including 15 starts before this new assignment, Richardson has completed 179 of 354 passes for 2,408 yards, eleven passing touchdowns and thirteen interceptions. He also owns 640 rushing yards and ten rushing touchdowns. His career record as a starter is 8–7. It is a small, injury-interrupted sample, and it presents a genuine contradiction: enough game-changing rushing production to intrigue a coach, but a completion percentage barely above fifty that would be an enormous obstacle over a full season.

Richardson has not started a regular-season game since Week 16 of the 2024 campaign. His development was disrupted by injuries, changes in standing and a 2025 pregame orbital injury. Earlier this year, he and the club explored a trade that did not materialize. He returned to serve as Jones’ backup, and for months his most notable contribution was being prepared to help if asked. That makes Friday’s promotion less of a triumphant culmination than an unexpected reopening of an assessment the franchise thought it had put aside.

Steichen emphasized Richardson’s maturation as a professional and the benefit of a full week preparing as the starter. The distinction is important. Studying as a backup is not identical to running first-team practice, setting the protection calls and preparing the offense around a specific quarterback’s habits. The new starter now has time to build those connections before Indianapolis’ next game against the New York Giants. He will still have to translate classroom understanding into correct choices with rushers closing in.

The obvious temptation is to design an offense around Richardson’s legs. Read-option looks, movement passes and the threat of a quarterback keeper can force linebackers to hesitate and create space that ordinary dropback football has not consistently produced. Those are legitimate tools, especially for an offense searching for a spark. But a scheme cannot become an elaborate escape hatch from the basic requirement to complete intermediate throws and punish defenses that crowd the line of scrimmage.

The more convincing early evidence would come from mundane plays: making the correct hot read on third down, delivering a catchable ball in rhythm, throwing away a broken play and reaching the red zone without donating possession. A spectacular twenty-yard scramble makes a highlight. A sequence of clean five-yard decisions is what turns an athletic prospect into a trustworthy starter. Richardson needs both, with extra attention to the latter.

Nor is the assignment guaranteed to remain exclusively his. Steichen has acknowledged that third-string quarterback Riley Leonard could receive opportunities and that the staff will evaluate the position from week to week. That is not a ringing guarantee of a new franchise cornerstone. It is the language of a coaching staff determined to collect information. Richardson has been handed the first chance to provide it, not the verdict.

His opportunity is substantial all the same. A late-season audition means facing opponents playing to win, not preseason defenses running simplified looks. It means carrying a game plan while coping with the consequences of mistakes. If he shows clearer processing and consistent ball placement, the Colts will have reason to reconsider their next quarterback investment. If he only produces scattered explosive moments, they will have learned that the ceiling remains more attractive than the floor.

The Quarterback Is Changing. The Broken Offense Is Not.

Jonathan Taylor of the Indianapolis Colts carrying the football during an NFL game

Indianapolis has not been keeping a healthy, stable team together while waiting for one quarterback to find form. The organization dismissed longtime general manager Chris Ballard following an early-season defeat and later traded several major names, including defensive lineman DeForest Buckner, guard Quenton Nelson and receivers Josh Downs and Keenan Allen. Those decisions may make sense as parts of a reset, but they also remove experienced contributors whom any young quarterback would prefer to have around him.

The departures matter differently by position. Losing an established offensive lineman affects protection communication, interior power and the confidence with which an offense can call longer-developing concepts. Losing receivers alters route familiarity, separation options and the defense’s calculation about where a quarterback wants to go with the ball. Richardson can add a running threat, but it would be a mistake to expect a change behind center to erase the combined effect of those losses.

One of the more useful measures is team scoring rather than the quarterback’s individual highlight reel. The Colts are averaging 19.2 points a game, among the lower marks in the league. It would be misleading to claim every one of those missing points is the responsibility of Jones or that Richardson alone can restore them. Indianapolis must also establish cleaner early-down execution, avoid negative plays and turn reasonable field position into drives that extend beyond a handful of snaps.

Jonathan Taylor remains a natural reference point for how to relieve pressure. A credible rushing attack can keep the offense on schedule, reduce the number of desperate third-and-long throws and let a mobile quarterback threaten a defense in multiple directions. Taylor’s value does not disappear when the passing game becomes unpredictable. The challenge is to create formations and blocking looks that make his running lanes credible without telegraphing every handoff.

Richardson’s mobility could make that job easier by changing the arithmetic at the point of attack. When the quarterback is a genuine runner, one defender may have to account for him instead of attacking the running back immediately. Play-action and designed movement can build from that hesitation. Yet this only works for more than a few drives if Richardson also connects on throws when a safety creeps forward. A defense that can ignore the passing threat will eventually crowd the box and make the supposedly creative run game ordinary.

The coaches must also decide how much complexity to install. Rebuilding an offensive identity during the season is not the same as assembling one over an offseason. Reducing the menu to concepts the remaining players know well may produce a cleaner performance than unveiling a large collection of exotic looks. Coaches should want the quarterback identifying coverage quickly and getting to the right answer, rather than merely memorizing an endless list of new plays.

Turnovers are the obvious standard. Jones’ sixteen giveaways through eleven starts made sustained offense brutally difficult. Richardson’s earlier career interceptions show he cannot assume the ball will take care of itself just because his legs add a different dimension. The Colts can survive an occasional aggressive deep shot; they cannot survive recurring short fields handed to opponents. A responsible, moderately productive offense would be meaningful progress from the Houston collapse.

The defense and special teams are part of the context, too. A quarterback starting from behind every week faces different risks than one supported by reliable stops and field position. Indianapolis’ recent results suggest no part of the roster should be exempt from examination. Richardson will be judged as a quarterback, but a convincing Colts rebuild will demand that the entire team stop looking like a collection of disconnected emergency measures.

The Giants Game Is an Audition, Not a Franchise Referendum

Colts head coach Shane Steichen speaking to reporters at the Indianapolis football facility

Richardson’s next scheduled start is against the New York Giants on Sunday, November 29. The matchup has an almost too-neat narrative hook: Jones spent the opening chapter of his career with the Giants, while the Colts now begin the next phase without him. But the more valuable story is not revenge or coincidence. It is whether Richardson can execute a prepared game plan with a full week of first-team practice and make the coaching staff believe the remaining season will teach it something useful.

Nobody should expect one afternoon to settle the argument. Richardson could play a clean game against a vulnerable opponent without proving he can handle the weekly adjustments required of an NFL starter. He could also make two highly visible mistakes while displaying real improvements in diagnosis and timing. The evaluation needs to look beyond a final passer rating and the number of viral scrambles. Which throws did he attempt? How often did he beat pressure with a decision rather than pure speed?

On early downs, the Colts should be looking for manageable yardage, particularly after the previous week’s inability to establish any lasting rhythm. Staying ahead of the chains would give Richardson opportunities to use his full skill set instead of repeatedly asking him to rescue third-and-long. Short completions that create second-and-medium are not aesthetically thrilling, but they are how a young quarterback buys the offense the right to be aggressive later.

On passing downs, the test changes. Richardson has to identify the rush, understand where an uncovered receiver or checkdown should appear and deliver with a repeatable base. A coach can design movement to help him, but opponents will eventually force him to operate from the pocket. His previous accuracy struggles make this particularly important. A few uncontested deep completions cannot substitute for consistent handling of the intermediate game.

In the red zone, the physical upside is impossible to ignore. Richardson’s career rushing touchdowns show that defenders must account for him near the goal line. The Colts should be able to threaten a designed quarterback run and still punish a defense that shifts too much attention toward the edge. The trick will be using those possibilities without exposing him to unnecessary punishment. A smart plan maximizes his versatility while giving him sustainable routes to score.

Steichen has also kept open the possibility of playing Riley Leonard later in the season. That makes the evaluation more complicated but potentially more informative. If Richardson struggles, Indianapolis may want a comparison within the same roster and scheme. If he produces enough stable play, the team may prefer to keep gathering evidence over several consecutive starts. Either approach should be explained by the quality of the quarterback’s decisions, not a reflexive reaction to each weekend’s scoreboard.

The front office faces an equally consequential task. Indianapolis dealt its 2027 first-round pick in the Sauce Gardner trade, limiting the simple option of turning a poor finish into the very top of the next draft. That fact raises the cost of a failed development bet, but it must not pressure the club into inventing confidence it has not earned. Richardson’s talent is real; so are the unknowns. Scouting, roster construction and coherent coaching will matter whatever the verdict on him becomes.

Jones’ departure has made the season more honest about its destination. Indianapolis is not dressing up a 3–8 record as a hidden playoff push. It is taking the risk of live evaluation, which is more defensible than clinging to a plan it no longer believes in. The Giants game will be the first major clue. The useful verdict will require several weeks of protection, decision-making and composure against defensive answers that change as opponents learn what Richardson can do.

Daniel Jones gave Indianapolis a brief glimpse of quarterback stability and a much longer reminder of how quickly the NFL can turn that promise into a cost. His recovery from a severe injury and the effort he invested in the Colts deserve recognition; neither makes the 2026 production acceptable. Waiving him was a decisive organizational choice, not a complete explanation of everything that went wrong.

Anthony Richardson now receives the one thing a highly drafted quarterback with unfinished business most needs: meaningful starts. His physical potential can change how opponents defend Indianapolis, but a successful audition will be measured in clean reads, catchable throws, protected possessions and an offense that functions when there is no heroic escape available.

The Colts have six games left to distinguish between an unusually difficult environment and another quarterback plan that cannot survive contact with reality. For Richardson, that is an opportunity. For Indianapolis, it is overdue homework.

Voltar para o blogue

Deixe um comentário