Bucky Irving Ran Through Dallas — but Three Takeaways Won the Night
GOATIFYThe Dallas Cowboys had a chance to move above .500 at home against a Tampa Bay Buccaneers team that had not won a game. Instead, Thursday night ended with the Bucs celebrating a 24-16 upset, a rookie quarterback protecting the football and a Dallas offense trying to explain three giveaways. Bucky Irving supplied the biggest plays, but the decisive story was how many ways Tampa Bay found to control the game.
Irving finished with a career-high 165 rushing yards and two total touchdowns. Undrafted quarterback Jalon Daniels completed 19 of 25 passes for 189 yards and a score in his second NFL start, filling in for the injured Baker Mayfield. The Bucs ran for 241 yards as a team, won the possession battle by almost 19 minutes and forced three second-half turnovers. Those numbers tell a more complete story than the eight-point margin: Tampa Bay was not merely waiting for Dallas to make mistakes. It created the conditions that made those mistakes matter.
Bucky Irving beat Dallas at two completely different speeds
At first, Tampa Bay's ground game looked like a way to keep Dak Prescott off the field. The Buccaneers answered Dallas's opening touchdown with a 15-play, 73-yard drive that lasted 10 minutes and 58 seconds. Daniels converted difficult situations, penalties helped extend the possession and Irving caught a five-yard touchdown pass just after the second quarter began. One drive had consumed almost an entire quarter. That is a punishing formula for a defense even before explosive runs enter the picture.
Then the third quarter began, and Irving changed the tempo in a single snap. His 72-yard burst carried Tampa Bay from its own territory to the Dallas 14. Emeka Egbuka scored on a 14-yard jet sweep on the very next play, turning a 10-7 halftime deficit into a 14-10 lead. The same offense that had required nearly 11 minutes to finish one touchdown drive needed just two plays and one minute to finish another.
That contrast matters more than any one highlight. Dallas could not consistently control the interior, set the edge or force the Bucs to stay behind the chains. Irving averaged 7.9 yards on 21 carries; Tampa Bay's 241 rushing yards dwarfed the Cowboys' 50. A team built to lean on Prescott's passing game found itself playing from behind while its defense repeatedly surrendered manageable situations and long gains.
Irving also scored from a yard out after a 64-yard completion to Tez Johnson, giving him a rushing touchdown and a receiving touchdown in the same game. The production was not an isolated statistical outburst: the early grind kept Dallas's offense watching, while the second-half burst forced it to chase. For Tampa Bay, that balance is a workable blueprint even when Mayfield returns. For Dallas, it was evidence that the run-defense issue cannot be solved simply by adding one more cornerback.
Jalon Daniels won by taking the throws Dallas gave him
Daniels did not need to imitate Mayfield's entire offense to win his second start. He needed to be decisive with the ball, use the opportunities created by the run game and avoid handing Dallas extra possessions. The rookie delivered a clean passing line: 19 completions on 25 attempts, 189 yards, one touchdown and no interceptions. That was a sharp contrast with the three picks he threw in his first start against Green Bay four days earlier.
The contrast is not proof that the undrafted quarterback has suddenly become a finished NFL starter. Dallas's defense allowed Tampa Bay to establish the run and repeatedly gave the rookie favorable situations. But Daniels still had to execute. His touchdown pass to Irving came at the end of the long first-half march. In the third quarter, with the Cowboys reeling after an interception, Daniels found Tez Johnson open for a 64-yard gain that set up Irving's short rushing score. A completion of that size was exactly what Tampa Bay needed to punish a defense that had already lost its footing.
One of the most telling plays did not become a touchdown. After KaVontae Turpin lost a kickoff return, Tampa Bay faced third-and-21 from the Dallas 48. Daniels connected with Egbuka for 21 yards, preserving a drive that ended in a field goal and stretched the lead to 24-10. In a game decided by eight points, that conversion made Dallas's comeback task materially harder.
Mayfield is expected to miss at least another game with a dislocated thumb, so Tampa Bay needs this version of Daniels to be repeatable rather than spectacular. The important signs are process-related: taking the available throw, working with the rushing attack and letting the defense make the bigger plays. He did not have to win a shootout with Prescott. He had to keep Tampa Bay out of the turnover spiral that Dallas entered.
Three Dallas turnovers turned a comeback into another warning
Dallas had enough passing production to make the score competitive. Prescott threw for 316 yards, and George Pickens supplied nine catches for 130 yards and a touchdown. The Cowboys even put together a 99-yard fourth-quarter touchdown drive after Tampa Bay failed to score from the one-yard line. For a moment, an improbable escape was still available.
But the turnover ledger told the story that yardage could not. Prescott's first interception came on a ball that ricocheted through traffic and ended up with Yaya Diaby. The Cowboys then allowed the 64-yard Daniels-to-Johnson play and Irving's short touchdown. On the following kickoff, Turpin lost the ball after a hit by Miles Killebrew, and Kevin Knowles recovered. Tampa Bay converted the extra possession into a field goal. Two mistakes, separated by only a few minutes of game time, helped turn a four-point deficit into a 14-point hole.
Prescott gave Dallas another chance by directing the long touchdown march and finding Pickens in the end zone. The failed two-point conversion left the Cowboys eight points behind, but the defense forced a punt and the offense moved back into scoring range. Then a pass intended for Jake Ferguson deflected upward and Alex Anzalone secured the interception with just over a minute remaining. Irving's final 22-yard run helped the Bucs exhaust the clock. It was the perfect ending for Tampa Bay's run-first approach and a brutal summary of Dallas's night.
There were reasons the Cowboys' offense looked less settled than it had against Houston. CeeDee Lamb, fresh off 17 catches and 189 yards in Week 4, managed only two receptions for nine yards before leaving with a quadriceps problem. Recently acquired cornerback Joey Porter Jr. was a late scratch because of illness, denying the defense another expected contributor. Those absences matter, but they do not erase the 241 rushing yards conceded or the three giveaways. At 2-3, Dallas has a bye-like gap before visiting Green Bay on October 18; it needs answers that go beyond getting healthy.
Tampa Bay moves to 1-4, not to instant contender status. Yet it showed a coherent route to winning: make the opponent defend both long possessions and explosive runs, let the rookie quarterback manage the game, and turn defensive takeaways into points. That is far more useful than a narrow victory built entirely on luck.
Thursday's upset was a warning about two teams moving in opposite directions for one night. The Buccaneers finally paired Irving's explosive talent with disciplined quarterback play and opportunistic defense. The Cowboys generated yards but surrendered the clock, the ground game and the ball. Tampa Bay's first win does not wipe away an 0-4 start, and Dallas's third loss does not decide its season. Both teams, though, now have unusually clear evidence of what they must repeat—or fix—before their next games on October 18.
Shop GOATIFY NFL and American football shirts, hoodies and stickers.
